Five Common FMLA Myths That Create Real Problems for Employers
Reading Time: 10 minutes - Employees never have to say the word FMLA. Once a supervisor hears enough to suggest a covered absence, the employer's obligations begin.
- PTO and FMLA answer different questions. PTO decides whether the employee is paid, FMLA decides whether the job is protected, and the two can run together.
- FMLA can be continuous, intermittent, or a reduced schedule. Intermittent bonding leave follows a different rule than medically necessary leave.
- An incomplete or vague certification can be sent back in writing, with 7 calendar days to cure it.
- Exhausting 12 weeks does not automatically end employment. The ADA analysis usually comes next.
Most FMLA trouble does not begin with a denied leave request. It begins with a supervisor who does not recognize the clues, a certification that is accepted while still incomplete, or an assumption that paid time off and FMLA are separate questions. The fix is a clearer process, not a longer policy.
The Family and Medical Leave Act sounds straightforward: eligible employees may receive job-protected leave for qualifying family and medical reasons. In practice, FMLA administration is rarely that simple.
The biggest problems often do not start with an employer intentionally denying leave. They start with a supervisor who does not recognize a potential FMLA situation, an incomplete certification that is handled incorrectly, or an assumption that paid time off and FMLA are separate issues.
Here are five common FMLA myths, where employers tend to get tripped up, and practical steps you can take to reduce complications.
Myth 1: “The employee has to ask for FMLA.”
Employees do not need to say “FMLA,” complete a formal leave request, or identify the law by name before the employer may have an obligation to respond.
An employee only needs to lay the groundwork with enough information to indicate their absences may be covered. Informal notice from the employee may develop over time and only needs to be sufficient to alert the employer to a potential FMLA situation for the employer to take action.
This information might materialize through comments such as:
- “My child’s doctor’s appointments are becoming more frequent.”
- “I am struggling at home and need to take some time off.”
- “I will need to leave early every Monday and Friday for physical therapy.”
- “I have another appointment related to the condition I told you about.”
- “My migraines are getting worse, and I may need to miss work periodically.”
The employee may tell HR, but just as often, the employee tells their supervisor or even a co-worker. Once a supervisor has enough information suggesting that absences may be FMLA-related, the organization is considered aware of the situation and their compliance obligations begin.
Where employers get tripped up
A manager treats each absence as a separate attendance issue because the employee never requested a “leave of absence.” By the time HR learns what is happening, the employee has accumulated attendance points or received discipline.
How to prevail
Train supervisors to recognize potential triggers and escalate them to HR. Managers do not need to diagnose the condition or decide whether the employee qualifies. They need to recognize clues and ask neutral questions such as:
- Is the absence related to your own health or a family member’s health?
- How long do you expect to be out?
FMLA Manager Decision Tree
Directs managers to ask limited follow-up questions and send possible or uncertain situations to HR for review. Add it to supervisor training: a well-written policy will not protect the organization if supervisors do not know when to use it.
Open it in the Member Hub
Not a Catapult member yet? Join Catapult to get this and the rest of the HR toolbox.
Myth 2: “If the employee has PTO, we do not need to address FMLA yet.”
Paid time off and FMLA answer two different questions.
PTO addresses whether the employee will be paid. FMLA addresses whether eligible leave is job-protected. FMLA leave may be unpaid, or it may run at the same time as employer-provided paid leave.
Allowing an employee to use PTO without evaluating FMLA can delay required notices, create inconsistent leave treatment, and potentially give the employee more time away from work than the employer intended.
For example, suppose an employee uses four weeks of PTO for surgery. If the employer waits until the PTO is exhausted to begin the FMLA process, it may create confusion about whether those first four weeks counted toward the employee’s FMLA entitlement.
Where employers get tripped up
- Assumption that approved PTO automatically resolves the absence.
- Managers, HR, and a third-party leave administrator use different leave dates.
- The handbook does not clearly explain when paid leave runs concurrently with FMLA.
- An employee receiving workers’ compensation or disability benefits is handled the same way as an employee using ordinary PTO, even though the rules under those plans may differ.
How to prevail
Review the reason for the absence when the employer first receives enough information to suggest that FMLA may apply. Do not wait for the employee to use all available PTO.
Provide the required notices promptly, communicate whether paid leave will run concurrently with FMLA, and make sure HR, payroll, supervisors, and any leave administrator are using the same dates.
Practical tip: Use one leave-tracking record that shows:
- First date of absence
- Date the employer learned the potential FMLA reason
- Eligibility determination
- Notice dates
- Certification deadline
- Approved frequency and duration
- FMLA time used
- PTO or other paid benefits applied concurrently
The U.S. Department of Labor’s FMLA Employer Guide follows the leave process from the employee’s initial notice through certification, designation, benefits continuation, and restoration. Review the DOL FMLA Employer Guide.
Myth 3: “FMLA has to be taken in one continuous block.”
FMLA leave may be continuous, intermittent, or taken through a reduced work schedule when the applicable requirements are met.
Intermittent leave may cover separate periods of absence for the same qualifying reason. A reduced schedule may change the employee’s usual number of working hours per day or week. Chronic conditions and treatment-related appointments typically result in intermittent or reduced schedule leave.
Bonding leave is an important distinction. Under FMLA, intermittent bonding leave generally requires employer approval, while medically necessary intermittent leave is handled differently. State leave laws may also provide additional rights.
FMLA Bonding Time
Catapult’s deeper look at how bonding leave differs from medically necessary intermittent leave, and where employer approval comes into play.
Open it in the Member Hub
Not a Catapult member yet? Join Catapult to get this and the rest of the HR toolbox.
Where employers get tripped up
Intermittent leave becomes difficult when:
- The certification says “as needed” without an estimated frequency or duration.
- The employee’s absences exceed the certified pattern.
- Monday and Friday absences begin to appear regularly.
- Supervisors apply attendance points before checking with HR.
- Employers assume that a suspicious pattern proves misuse.
- Different managers require different call-in procedures.
How to prevail
Start with the certification, not an assumption about the employee’s motives. Track leave accurately and compare actual absences with the certified frequency and duration.
Employers may generally enforce usual and customary call-in procedures unless unusual circumstances prevent the employee from following them. Document absence patterns, use the prescribed certification and recertification process allowed under FMLA, and follow up when circumstances change or the employer receives information that casts objective doubt on the stated need for leave.
Practical tip: When an employee reports an intermittent absence, ask consistent, limited questions:
- Is this absence related to your approved FMLA condition?
- What is the expected duration?
Myth 4: “We have to accept whatever is written on the medical certification.”
Employers do not need an employee’s complete medical record, but they also do not have to accept a certification that is incomplete, vague, or insufficient.
A certification may create problems when it:
- Omits necessary information.
- Uses unclear terms such as “ongoing” or “as needed” without further explanation.
- Does not estimate the probable duration of the condition.
- Does not provide an expected frequency or duration for intermittent absences.
An employer should use the Designation Notice, form WH-382, to identify certification deficiencies in writing and provide the employee 7 calendar days to cure them.
Where employers get tripped up
Some employers approve unclear certifications because they are hesitant to ask follow-up questions. Others move too quickly in the opposite direction and deny leave without giving the employee an opportunity to correct missing or insufficient information.
Healthcare provider contact must be carefully controlled and handled only by an authorized representative in accordance with FMLA requirements.
How to prevail
Use a consistent certification review process:
- Confirm that all required sections have been completed.
- Identify exactly what is missing or unclear.
- Notify the employee of the deficiency in writing.
- Allow the required opportunity to cure the certification.
- Limit any authentication or clarification request to permissible information.
- Consider recertification when allowed and supported by the circumstances.
- Document every step.
FMLA Medical Certification Review Checklist
Work the certification review the same way every time, especially when several HR team members or a third-party administrator touch leave. Do not rely on memory.
Open it in the Member Hub
Not a Catapult member yet? Join Catapult to get this and the rest of the HR toolbox.
Myth 5: “Once 12 weeks are exhausted, we can automatically terminate employment.”
FMLA does not require indefinite leave. However, the end of FMLA is not the end of the employer’s obligations.
If the employee cannot return when FMLA leave is exhausted, the employer needs to consider whether another policy or law applies. The Americans with Disabilities Act is most likely the next analysis employers need to examine, but workers’ compensation, state leave laws, or an employer’s own leave policy could present additional considerations.
Where employers get tripped up
- A termination letter is prepared automatically for the day after FMLA expires.
- No one asks whether the employee needs additional leave or another workplace change.
- The employee is returned to a position that is not virtually identical to the one they left.
- Performance issues are raised for the first time immediately after leave.
- A supervisor makes comments suggesting that the employee’s leave created hardship for the team.
- An employee’s protected absence is counted against them in a performance or attendance decision.
The most common employer errors stem from failure to reinstate employees according to the FMLA regulations, lack of supervisor training, retaliation (perceived or otherwise) against employees for requesting or using FMLA, and failing to address performance problems before leave.
How to prevail
Before making a decision at the end of FMLA, pause and review:
- Can the employee return to the same position?
- Has the employee requested additional leave or another adjustment?
- Were performance or conduct concerns documented before the leave?
- Would the same decision have been made if the employee had not taken FMLA?
- Have similar situations been handled consistently?
Practical tip: Begin your ADA process immediately at the exhaustion of FMLA if the employee has not returned. Bring in a Catapult HR Advisor or our employment law advice when the facts are complex.
ADA & Accommodations Toolkit
Guidance for running the accommodation analysis that usually follows an exhausted FMLA entitlement.
Open it in the Member Hub
Not a Catapult member yet? Join Catapult to get this and the rest of the HR toolbox.
The best FMLA protection is a consistent process
Most FMLA complications are not caused by one dramatic mistake. They develop through smaller process gaps:
- A supervisor waits too long to notify HR.
- An absence is coded incorrectly.
- A certification deficiency is not documented.
- Intermittent leave is not tracked against the approved frequency.
- A return-to-work decision is made without considering other obligations.
- Similar employees receive different answers.
The strongest approach is not to make the policy longer. It is to make the process clearer.
Train supervisors. Centralize leave decisions. Use consistent notices and checklists. Track dates carefully. Address performance concerns when they occur, not after an employee requests leave. And when FMLA ends, stop long enough to determine whether another obligation begins.
That is how employers move from reacting to leave problems to managing them with consistency and confidence.
FMLA questions employers ask most
Does an employee have to say “FMLA” to trigger the employer’s obligations?
No. An employee only needs to give enough information to suggest the absence may be covered. Comments about a worsening condition, recurring appointments, or needing time for a family member’s health can be enough. Once a supervisor has that information, the organization is considered aware and its obligations begin.
Can an employee use PTO instead of FMLA?
PTO and FMLA answer two different questions. PTO decides whether the employee is paid; FMLA decides whether the leave is job-protected. The two can run at the same time. Waiting until PTO runs out to start the FMLA process can delay required notices and create confusion about how much entitlement was used.
Does FMLA leave have to be taken all at once?
No. FMLA leave may be continuous, intermittent, or taken as a reduced work schedule when the requirements are met. Chronic conditions and treatment appointments commonly result in intermittent or reduced schedule leave. Intermittent bonding leave generally requires employer approval, which is a different rule from medically necessary intermittent leave.
What can an employer do about an incomplete medical certification?
An employer does not have to accept a certification that is incomplete, vague, or insufficient. Identify the deficiency in writing using the Designation Notice, form WH-382, and give the employee 7 calendar days to cure it. Any authentication or clarification contact with the healthcare provider must be handled only by an authorized representative.
Can an employer terminate an employee once 12 weeks of FMLA are used?
Not automatically. FMLA does not require indefinite leave, but the end of FMLA is not the end of the employer’s obligations. The Americans with Disabilities Act is usually the next analysis, and workers’ compensation, state leave laws, or the employer’s own policy may also apply.
- U.S. Department of Labor, The Employer’s Guide to the Family and Medical Leave Act
- U.S. Department of Labor, Designation Notice, form WH-382 (PDF)
This article provides general HR information and is not legal advice. FMLA decisions are fact-specific, and employers should review applicable federal, state, and local requirements.
Stephanie Dillon is Catapult's Lead Senior HR Advisor. She advises member employers on employee relations, workplace investigations, and performance management, along with the compliance questions that most often catch employers out, including FMLA and ADA, OSHA, wage and hour, EEO, immigration, and the NLRA. She has worked across industries rather than in a single sector.
